Indoor Trainers: Making Peace with Riding Inside
Indoor training options have gotten complicated with all the trainer types and apps flying around. As someone who resisted indoor training for years — riding a bike that goes nowhere seemed pointless — I learned everything there is to know after moving somewhere with real winters. Today, I’ll share the reality: trainers aren’t about replacing outdoor rides, they’re about not losing fitness when outside isn’t an option.
The Basic Categories
Probably should have led with this section, honestly.
Wheel-on trainers: Your rear tire presses against a roller. Cheap ($150-400), easy setup, works with any bike. Downsides: tire wear, noise, less realistic feel.
Direct-drive trainers: Remove your rear wheel, attach the bike directly to the trainer. More expensive ($500-1200+), but quieter, no tire wear, more realistic road feel. If you’re riding inside regularly, worth the upgrade.
Smart trainers: Either type can be “smart” — meaning they connect to apps and adjust resistance automatically. Follow a virtual course that goes uphill? The trainer gets harder. This costs more but makes indoor riding dramatically less boring.
What Actually Matters
Noise: That’s what makes this endearing to us apartment dwellers — quiet trainers mean not annoying roommates or neighbors. Wheel-on trainers can sound like small aircraft. Direct-drive is much quieter.
Connectivity: ANT+ or Bluetooth to connect to apps like Zwift, TrainerRoad, or Rouvy. Without this, indoor training is mind-numbing.
Starting Simple
A basic smart trainer plus a fan and a towel gets you 90% of the indoor training experience. Add apps as needed. Don’t overcomplicate it until you know you’ll actually use it.
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest articles delivered to your inbox.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.